I've been using this mascara for a few years now. It definitely is vibrant and it does the trick. I'm not gonna say it's premium sometimes I do have to reapply and every now and then it does feel a little bit clumpy at the end of the day but for $10-$15…. I love it. I have another one that I buy for $35 and it definitely lasts longer but I keep going back to this one cause it's so much cheaper and it doesn't look any different. It just doesn't last quite as long. I'd rather reapply than spend a ton more money.

I have used this product for the last 8 to ten years. Clumps constantly fall in my eyes,hard to remove, and my eyelashes has never been so sparse since using this. Why would you switch a perfectly good product to this garbage ???

I have bought this product a couple of times. I like the result but way too much mascara comes out of the tube. It's such a waste to have to wipe it down to use it.

I recently purchased your mascara in the Burgundy shade, and unfortunately, I was disappointed with the results. The main issue is that the mascara weighed down my lashes and completely took away the curl, even though I had curled them beforehand. I also chose the Burgundy shade because I was expecting a noticeable burgundy/wine tone, but unfortunately, the color was barely visible on my lashes. It looked almost like a regular dark mascara. I was really excited to try this product, so I wanted to share my experience and see if there is anything you can recommend or if there is a way to resolve this issue.

I am extremely disappointed in this mascara. Clumpy. Way too much mascara on the brush.

Great mascara, no clumping, but I will be throwing my barely used tube in the garage! Good luck getting it off! Lost lashes trying, save your money and your lashes, avoid this formula.

Dry mascara. No longer voluminous. Unfortunate. I have been using it for 20 years. It's just really too bad that I have to go out and find a new brand after all these years. Where is the loyalty L'Oreal?

This was my favourite mascara. The new formula is terrible. It no longer gives my eyelashes that full and thick look. Doesn't go on like it used to and it is difficult to remove almost like a waterproof mascara. I have been using this mascara for 15 years but very disappointed with the new formula.

I've worn this mascara for more than 15 years. I used to love it, but the formula sees to have changed. It has big clumps and it flakes, so I'm looking for another brand. I have very sensitive eyes, and my eyes water, so I need a waterproof mascara, for sensitive eyes.

I find this product to be very clumpy and comes out of the tube with way too much product on it. There doesn't seem to have a ridge on the inside of the tube to squeeze excess product off when you remove the brush to use it. Because of this my lashes turn out thick and chunky and I have no control with my lashes. The one I have is YD01 in the color black.