It has one small drawback: for eyes with puffy eyelids, the eyeliner can smudge a little. However, if you use eyeshadow as a base beforehand, this issue can be solved.

Love the look of this pencil but cannot sharpen it! The twist at the end of the stick is not working!! Very disappointing

Really bad and get blur in a few hours not gonna buy it again

I got it on sale. It looked pretty promising at the beginning but 4 hrs later I look like a racoon. I'm able to rub it off my eyes clean with just my fingers after wearing it for a few hours. I think the formula just doesn't sit well on dryer skin types.

After trying countless cream eyeliners this is the best cream eyeliner. Stays on for 24hrs without smudging no matter the weather . Pls bing back the espresso colour bec the black is too black. You have the market on the espresso colour.

Have been using the brown eye gel for years but lately can only fine Black. Too dark. Tried to buy brown online and keep getting message try later. What gives? Hae used pencels and liquids but the gel in small glass pot with brush for application is the best.

I've used this product for a decade, but the change in brush has been a huge negative. It's harder to apply the gel with the bent brush and with a proper cap to the brush it hardens and also application harder. My brush also has cracked at the bend due to need for more frequent cleaning. I find I can no longer apply gel liner accurately and precisely with the new brush. Please bring back the old brush. I otherwise love this product and how long lasting and non-smudging it is, it is literally the only makeup I wear everyday.

I have bought at least seven of these hoping that each one would work. As soon as the first part of the pencil comes down and you use it you cannot make it come out you can take it apart and see that there's more colored pencil inside the tube but it will not make it come out I can take pictures and prove this to you I have at least seven of them and I would like my money back I have wasted Time after Time after Time. I use Maybelline products but this is horrible there's another product called infallible and I think they were trying to mimic it I will buy that from now on I would like my money back take it from me you can only use it until the part that comes out of the pencil is gone the rest of it will never come out you can twist that thing over and over it will not come out

This product does not go on smoothly and the tip after the first use, is dull. I give this product two thumbs down.

I didn't care for this brand of eyeliner. Very light when applied and didn't last very long.