I am not impressed. The felt tip is dried right out

I got this eyeliner as a replacement because my usual liner wasn't in stock. It's truly awful. The felt tip liner doesn't work at all, I had to wet the brush to get it to leave any makeup on my skin. I had to rub it on my eyelids so hard that it hurt. As for the pencil side, it actually works pretty well, but there's no way to sharpen it. Overall I am super disappointed and will never buy this product again.

I was really excited to try this eyeliner. I have tried a few other Jason Wu beauty products and have been very pleased with them. This dual ended eyeliner is great. You can do really sharp lines with the fine tip end. It glides really well and dries quickly. The other end is great for thicker lines and creating a smudgy look. It doesn't skip and goes on smooth. It's two products in one which means one less thing to carry so very convenient for travel or being on-the-go.

I love a good duel liner. This one was easy to apply and it lasted all day. I'm used to using this type of eyeliner so I thought it was very easy to use. It came off well at night using makeup remover.

The reason this is called a dual liner is because you have two options. The traditional pencil liner (my preference) or the felt tip liner (great for hot dates!). The pencil goes on smooth and easy to apply, plus it is waterproof.

So who doesn't use liquid and dry eyeliner? I know that for me this was a plus. I like the liquid eyeliner for the top of my eyelid, and the dry one for my waterline. This eyeliner has the best of both worlds, one on each end. The liquid eyeliner at times can come out weak, I don't know if I should leave it down so that the liquid can set. But I did have a hard time a few times for the liquid to flow. The pencil part was amazing, it comes out really good and dark.

I absolutely love this eyeliner. I love the fact that it is a dual so it has a felt tip and a pencil side. It applies so smooth that anyone can use this. I struggle doing my own makeup but with this eyeliner, I can do it and looks like I have been doing it for years. My boys are in a lot of sports during the summer where I sweat alot and this amazing eyeliner last the whole time. This is my now favorite eyeliner! I'd definitely recommend this!

I am very happy with this liner. It goes on smoothly and it lasts throughout the day without wearing off or disappearing. So far it has not caused a reaction on my eyes as I tend to have sensitive skin especially around the eye area. I would highly recommend.

This liner is pretty cool. It's nice to have the pencil side and the felt tip in one. Both are waterproof (which is amazing). The finish they provide is matte which is so pretty. The color is a true black which I enjoy. This is a great product

I am always on the hunt for an eye pencil that lasts all day, that is easy to sharpen and that does not smudge. This one checks all of the boxes for me. This Jason Wu pencil is "intense black". It is is cruelty free, gluten free, parabens free, sulfate free, phythalates free and even fragrance free. It is also a vegan product. When put on very carefully, this did not smudge (a must for me). It has more of a matte finish to it. The felt tip portion had a learning curve for sure (directions are on the box), but once accomplished, I loved how dark and bold this part of the pencil was. Flawless! I liked how this was pretty easy to use. I find that with pencils that aren't as high quality as this one, you have to go over multiple times for the color to show up. Not the case with this one. With either side, going over it just once works for the first application. The pencil stayed on my eye most of the day. During a 10 hour work day, I had to apply towards the end of the day. It started to fade, but reapplying only took a second. I wish it would've lasted just a bit longer. A bonus is that it is water resistant. You do not even have to sharpen the pencil side (just twist), and it has lasted quite a while without me needing to replace this pencil. Good quality, water resistant and easy to use. Recommended!