I love the colors and duochromes of this product, but the set time is very long and can make it very hard to use without getting transfer to the upper lid.

I bought 3 of the available shades for a Mardi Gras party last February. They're incredibly long-lasting, they stay on until you're ready to take them off!! I ended up using them for more than the party as they're beautiful and go with so many of my clothes. The only problem I have experienced is that they're a bit hard to apply because if you mess up, they're harder to remove than regular liner. I highly recommend these brilliant liners.

This eyeliner compliments my blue eyes so well. I bought three colors and love them all!

This goes on clumpy, clogs in my eyelashes, feels like glue on my eyelids and especially at the corners. When I use makeup remover wipes, I have to scrub to get the crust of it off, sometimes resorting to cold cream. It's just overall unpleasant to wear... The colors are lovely, but it's just not worth the hassle. I decided to toss these after a handful of tries.

I had such high hopes for this product. The color concepts, the potential marketing design was perfect, but unfortunately that's all it was. It has so many technical flaws to this product, it's a totally shame it's needs a total re-haul, good concept though.

I've been using Stila's Stay All Day Chroma-Flash Liquid Eye Liner for about a year now across three shades - Mermaid, Peacock, and Firefly - and Mermaid is my favorite. Here's the thing: At first, I hate the feel of it on my eyes and putting it on was problematic but I kept coming back to this liner because there is genuinely nothing else like it. The color payoff is stunning, and the way the chrome shifts is just magical. Once you see it on, you understand why you'd put in the effort to figure it out. And there is effort involved. I didn't love it at first - I was using too much product, which left my lashes clumped and gave me a heavy, almost crusty feeling on my eyes. This stuff locks in seriously, so too much of it becomes very noticeable very fast. But once I dialed back the amount, and then tried layering it things changed. Some practice and dedication helped, too. A few things that made a big difference: For more depth: I start with Stila's Stay All Day waterproof liner first, then layer the Chroma-Flash over it. It really makes the color pop. This is just what's in my arsenal - I'm sure any dark liner would help. For keeping it off my lashes: Less product, better placement from practicing, and a spoolie immediately after to free up any lashes that get caught in the sweep across. For drying: I have hooded eyes, so I use a little air to speed up dry time. If I open my eyes too wide too soon, I'm cleaning up smudged liner from my upper lid. The staying power is real - it's also a commitment to remove the next day, which honestly I consider a plus. A year in, still emptying tubes and here to buy the new colors!

I purchased this in peacock and mermaid. While the colors are beautiful, the applicator is terrible and either globs the eyeliner on or is too dry, requiring you to dip back in with another glob coming out. Then that takes forever to dry. I would not purchase again.

So I tried all 3 of these in an Ulta store, thought they where beautiful! Ulta ran outta of them so I ordered straight from Stila. Ive used all 3 and omg they're not good! They run , drip and take forever to dry. Its looked like i went in the shower right after applying it! I saw on other people it'd be different colors. They're not! Lord i wont buy these again.. only good thing is they stay on your eyes not going on my eyelids,

Was hard to get off so thats definitely a plus! Love the colors! I definitely recommend a little eyelash fan to dry it faster so it doesnt transfer. The colors are gorgeous. Im wearing the color Peacock.

This is my absolute favorite new release from this year. I would love to see more shades!