Love the color! I don't like the way it applies, it is a bit more sticky and doesn't go on smooth but color over all is beautiful, I don't use it as often as I would like

I love the color of this eye liner. Most importantly, it is pretty water proof and dosent budge.

I use this eyeliner on my eyes and my lips it's versatile for me and love it!

Stays put! Beautiful pigment!

i'm not the best that eyeliner so this one is a little bit harder for me to use, but the color is gorgeous and the finish is very good as well

I've been using Stila liquid eyeliner for about 10 years love it. I was very excited to try this when it came out couldn't wait to use. Very disappointed. The eyeliner brush is very very thin and not strong enough to support the liquid. When trying to apply to lid the eyeliner it would not spread evenly the brush was getting tangled in my upper lashes (making clumps of eyeliner on my lashes. The brush needs to be sturdy enough to apply the liner. To wimpy for the product. Such a shame. Reached out to company haven't heard back. I tried an experiment. I took another brush (sturdy) from another brand liquid eyeliner and BINGO the Stila eyeliner spread along my lid evenly. The product is good & pretty but the applicator brush that comes with it sucks. 😢

This liquid eyeliner is so easy to use!! The shades are sunning!! I'm a bit bummed that that the cherry noir is sold out… :(. I purchased blue moon, midnight hour, and bronze blaze. All of the colors are pigmented well and stays on all day! It is actually a bit hard to take off… if that's the biggest issue I'm really happy. The color stars exactly where you put it without smearing or smudging. Now if I could just get my hands the cherry noir!! This is my first purchase from Stila cosmetics and I'm quite happy with my purchase.

The metallic shades are so good! Super pigmented and smooth to apply. The colors are bold and impactful and wear all day.

I love this stuff, goes on slick and easy. (It was a little wonky but that was user error 😆) Lasts almost all day!

I love the color, but everything else about this product was awful. It's really messy to work with. Even after shaking the bottle, it came out gloopy and stringy. I had to wipe the brush off because there was way too much product on it, but then it applied unevenly. It was really messy and difficult to create clean lines with the product being gloopy and the brush being too thick. There's ZERO wiggle room or flexibility for error with this product. It's impossible to remove without heavy-duty scrubbing and serious makeup removing products. I tried to clean up a a couple of tiny wobbles to my lines with a makeup removing wipe and it would not budge, no matter how hard I rubbed. And at the end of a 12-hour day I had to scrub hard at the tender skin on my eyelids to remove the product. In short, I love the color and wanted badly to like this product. But it was an absolute "NO" from me. I wish they'd come out with this Black Cherry color in the the Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, which is far easier to work with and stays put all day, but removes really easily when you wash your face (& can be touched up with a wipe).