Love the attached lid and it sharpens well with very few turns!

I have 10 of these eyeliners and I love them all! The formula is amazing. They are very creamy and glide on very smoothly. They blend easily, and once they set, they don't smudge or fade. Once dry, they are locked in place. These pencils are very waterproof and require eye make up remover to get off. The colours are highly pigmented and there is a vast array of colours available. These liners shine and have a glistening quality. One drawback for me is that I can not get these pencils to stay on my waterline. Recently, Lise Watier changed these pencils. Previously, they were traditional eye liner pencils that required sharpening. Each pencil contained 1.2g of product. They are now sold in retractable pencils, which contain 0.5 g of product. That is less than half as much as they used to contain! The worst part is that the cost has gone up! I wrote an email to the company expressing my disappointment and they responded with a generic letter that did not address my issue. I will no longer be purchasing these pencils. They are expensive, and now that they contain less than half of the product, they cost more than I'm willing to pay. An inexpensive alternative for pencils comparable in quality are the follow pencils: Essence Effect Eye Pencil Long-Lasting. Based on the quality and formula of these pencils, I recommend them, but because of the reduction in amount of product, I suggest exploring alternatives.

Works very well. Doesn't ruin my pencils like some others

It has attached lid so I can't lose it !!! It actually works great on the waxy pencils that always end up going in trash b/c they don't sharpen properly

I like that it has two sizes for even my larger pencil lipsticks. My old one didn't have an attached lid like this one so I eventually lost it. Keeps my make up bag cleaner.