Terrible mascara! I bought this when you discontinued the Voluminous Superstar thinking that it would be a good substitute - it isn't. It is not easy to remove and when it does finally come off, it leave little flakes in the sink. Please bring back the other one.

It's ok - the silver and black double extend ( without tubing ) was a much better mascara

I just bought this product yesterday. I'm highly disappointed. I had to apply many coats to get some colors on my lashes then they all clamped together. When it came to remove my makeup it was a nightmare. I didn't come off, I had to run my eyes so many times that at the end when I looked at the makeup removing pad I saw all my own lashes . It literally ripped off my eye lashes. Very disappointed.

Application très difficile et les cils collent ensemble. Ne fait pas ce qui est prévu

Not only is this the only tubing mascara I will use, this is the only MASCARA period I will use. Nothing else lengthens or thickens my lashes like this. The wear is unmatched, nothing else lasts this long and no smudging whatsoever.

I bought this because I have sensitive eyes and had read that tubing mascara was less likely to flake. That may be true but this mascara is very clumpy and hard to apply because of the clumps, and very difficult to remove with just soap and water. You literally have to pull it off your lashes. I will never buy it again.

This product is garbage. I bought a second tube thinking it must have been a bad batch and nope. It sticks to my skin top and bottom lashes, and over curls so much that the tips of my eyelashes bend backwards like hooks, actually making them look shorter. Have never had this problem with a mascara in the past. Perhaps the curl feature works for some people, I could get over that aspect if it wasn't for the clumping and sticking to my skin part which is the absolute worst. Sticky clumping over curling and gross.

I have been using this mascara for so long I can't remember when I started, I've tried rhets then go right back!

I have tried dozens and dozens of mascaras and I keep coming back to this one. Tubing mascaras are amazing, but typically are not water/sweat proof. I don't know if it's the base coat (thank you for fixing the gumminess L'Oréal!) but this mascara has lasted through golf tournaments in 90+ degree weather! It is by far one of the best for length and volume and is superior in its water resistance. On my wish list would be a nice warm brown shade, but I'm thrilled with this mascara and it will always be my #1

Pour moi c'est de loin le pire mascara que j'ai acheté. Aucun volume, il me fait des traces au-dessus des paupières et le soir ça me prend 30 minutes devant la télé pour reussir a l'enlever avec mes doigts même après avoir mis de l'eau. Très déçue pour le prix en plus.