Add me to the growing list of the disappointed. I have used the smudge-proof mascara for years and years. Since the Smokey Eye mascara is the "replacement" -- I purchased it-- but wish I hadn't. It does not apply well; it take SO many coats to even resemble what two coats of the other did for my lashes. It is not long-wearing whatsoever. It easily smears. One trip to the chiropractor and I had "raccoon eyes" that would not go away until I removed my makeup. I am throwing the tube away and am in search of a waterproof replacement.

I was overjoyed to finally find a perfect mascara with a perfect brush only to have it discontinued. Smokey eye mascara does not compare. Please bring no smudge back !

Please bring back the no smudge waterproof mascara. It is the only one that doesn't run and cause raccoon eyes. Some of us have oily skin so prefer smudge free waterproof. The smoky eye smears under eye.....not a good look.

Soooo very disappointed the no smudge mascara has been discontinued. Please bring it back! I've already tried so many other options, including this Smokey eye mascara, and none compare. This one is nothing like it and should not be recommended as its replacement. It is not smudge proof nor does it go on the same.

Used Bobbi Brown no smudge mascara for a very long time. Apparently Smokey Eye Mascara is a recommended replacement for that product. It is very disappointing. It smudges easily and quickly. It does not add volume. Will have to find a new brand

Discontinued my favorite no smudge mascara. It was the only mascara that held up on my over 50 skin. Tried this Smokey eye mascara and was so disappointed!! Transfers above and below my eyes after about an hour. Looks terrible. Wish I could get a refund.

I like this - it goes on well, doesn't smudge, good color - not lengthening at all but no clumps or under eye issues.

Just LOVE this mascara! It's a jet black rich color. For me, I find that it thickens AND lengthens my lashes. A great buildable formula and perfect brush.

I had first received Smokey Eye Mascara as a sample with an order a while back. I really liked it and ordered a full-size. I'm so happy I did. This mascara goes on smoothly, not clumpy. When I don't wear my glasses, I curl my lashes with an eyelash curler, then apply 15 -20 swipes onto my lashes. WOW! My eyes look amazing. My lashes look thicker and longer. I have found it wears very well during the day. I don't end up with racoon eyes at the end of the day. Definitely found my Holy Grail mascara.

This mascara has minimal smudge during the day no lasts the whole time