I love the colors I bought, and they worked well. My black one broke immediately after using it once, however. I used multiple different eye pencil sharpeners, and it does appear to sharpen but it is incredibly hard and takes forever. I've considered resorting to my pocket knife, though I'm not sure that would work either.

I bought this today, I opened the product and the tip broke immediately. I couldn't even use it once, and there's no other product besides the tip shown at the top.

Tip broke instantly, and there is nothing more than the tip from what i can tell. I tried shaking it, twisting it in different places, nothing worked. Couldnt even use it once before i had to throw it away.

I bought the purple and red one and I'm pleasently surprised, the red is like tomato red and the purple is very vibrant

I brought this and within the first ten seconds of me using it, it broke. There is not product in there at all to get more so I'm very disappointed and would like a refund

I bought The covergirl upside down eyeliner. It only lasts for a few applications, before it's done. It appears like it twists to apply additional liner to the pencil. But it doesn't. Once you use what is on the stick. There is no more to us. Awfully expensive for an eyeliner stick that only lasts for two or three applications. I love the colors. So, very disappointed.